Background
HM Inspectors (HMI) undertake regular inspections of all MA provider types. These include local authorities, employers, managing agents, colleges, universities and independent training providers. Inspections are planned collaboratively between the provider and HMI. Skills Development Scotland (SDS) provides information on provider performance, including relevant data, to support the process. HMI evaluate the quality of training provision and the experiences and outcomes of apprentices and stakeholders, including employers.
Inspection evidence over the last three years (2023 to 2026) highlights a number of clear messages.
The MA sector remains fundamentally strong. Inspectors continue to identify:
- highly effective employer engagement
- strong apprentice support
- relevant workplace learning
- positive progression outcomes across most provider types
However, attainment, quality assurance and self-evaluation for improvement, meta-skills development and evidence of impact remain challenges within the sector.
Across the evidence base, the strongest providers combine positive apprentice experiences with measurable impact. They demonstrate strong attainment, systematic quality improvement arrangements, effective performance management and clear evidence of sustained outcomes.