Findings from public consultation on school inspections
We have published the findings of the public consultation on the future of school inspections and the Chief Inspector’s formal response. This marks a significant milestone in the transformation of inspection in Scotland.
The publication provides a detailed, independent analysis of responses. It sets out the initial direction of reform of school inspections as Scotland establishes a new, independent inspectorate.
Listening at scale to shape future inspection
The consultation (consult.gov.scot) gathered extensive feedback from Scotland’s education community. There were responses from 1,100 stakeholders and nearly 500 children and young people.
It represents the first of its kind for the inspectorate and sits at the heart of wider system reform. It explored key aspects of inspection, including who should be involved, how often inspections should take place, how findings should be reported, and how the voices of children and young people can be strengthened.
Responses revealed:
- a clear view that children and young people should have more opportunities to be involved in school inspection
- strong support for greater collaboration across the education system, including the role of associate assessors and senior leaders
- a shared desire for clearer, more accessible reporting focused on improvement
- mixed views on inspection frequency, grading and notification, highlighting areas for further discussion
Children and young people emphasised the importance of wellbeing, relationships, inclusion and feeling safe in school. Many prefer accessible formats such as video for sharing inspection feedback.
Chief Inspector sets out next steps
Responding to the findings, His Majesty’s Chief Inspector of Education, Ruth Binks, set out her vision for how inspection will evolve.
Initial priorities include:
- strengthening the role of associate assessors through a new national strategy
- expanding the role of school leaders and staff in inspection activity to build capacity for continuous improvement
- enhancing engagement with children and young people, including clearer communication and new opportunities to shape inspection work
- exploring improvements to reporting, ensuring that findings are clear, accessible and meaningful for all audiences
The Chief Inspector also confirmed that further decisions will be developed in collaboration with the new Advisory Council. This will represent learners, parents, practitioners and other stakeholders and help the inspectorate to shape the future inspection model.
Supporting reform under new legislation
The publication comes shortly after the establishment of His Majesty's Inspectorate of Education (HMIE) as a new, independent body on 1 April 2026, following the implementation of the Education (Scotland) Act 2025.
The Act sets out a strengthened statutory purpose for inspection, including:
- promoting improvement in the quality of education
- sharing effective practice
- providing assurance to the public
- informing national education policy
The consultation findings will inform HMIE’s forthcoming multi-year inspection plan, which will set out how inspections will operate in practice in the years ahead.
Engaging children and young people
A dedicated video response for children and young people, reflects their preference for engaging ways of understanding inspection findings.
This forms part of a wider commitment to ensure that the views of children and young people are not only heard but clearly reflected in how inspection is designed and delivered.
A transition period for change
The Chief Inspector has described academic year 2026 to 2027 as a transition year for HMIE. Work is underway to:
- establish the new inspectorate’s structures and governance
- implement reforms informed by the consultation
- develop new inspection frameworks and approaches
- ensure inspection is efficient, fair and trusted